Ending Slavery, Narrating Emancipation: Revolutionary Legacies in the French Anti-slavery Debate and “Silencing the Haitian Revolution”, 1814-1848

Publication date

Authors

ABSTRACT

This dissertation examines the nineteenth-century French debate on slavery and emancipation by analyzing its engagement with the antislavery legacies of the French Revolution and the Haitian Revolution. In revising the prior historiography’s preoccupation with the influence of the benchmark British example, it contends that the impacts of revolutionary abolition formed another vital factor in shaping French abolitionism and emancipation. For this purpose, this thesis charts the discursive mobilization of the revolutionary past’s divisive meanings concerning slavery and the controversial state of postindependence Haiti as the first postemancipation society in the French antislavery debate. This process seeks to rework Michel- Rolph Trouillot’s thesis and trace the complex practices and the procedure of “silencing the Haitian Revolution,” not reducible to “unthinkable.”

In order to reconstruct the discursive contestation over revolutionary legacies, this thesis is predicated on two approaches. First, it delves into the linkage between French domestic politics and antislavery issues. As the politics of memory over the French Revolution dominated French postrevolutionary politics, it excavates how narrating the history of the French and Haitian Revolutions became a crucial part of antislavery politics. From the Restoration to the July Monarchy, the shifting political positions of the antislavery elites in the regime deeply affected their changing uses and strategies of the representation of the Haitian Revolution and Haiti. Second, this thesis revamps the studies of French antislavery from a transatlantic perspective by examining the roles of three colonial groups: refugee planters of Saint-Domingue in Paris; free people of color from French colonies represented by Cyrille Bissette; and Haitian ruling elites intervening in metropolitan discussions. The study of these three groups illuminates the evolution of French antislavery at the nexus of metropolitan-colonial interactions and on a transatlantic scale. For these purposes, I mobilize a variety of instances in which the narratives of slavery and abolition were produced and contested: political tracts, historical books, parliamentary debates, antislavery associations, the press, the causes célèbres, and artistic representations.

This thesis works towards three goals. First, it reveals the key role of revolutionary examples in molding French antislavery discourse—in particular, the Haitian Revolution and post-1804 Haiti. By doing this, it provides an alternative explanation for the dynamics of French emancipation and also illuminates the Haitian Revolution’s discursive impact on French abolitionism. Second, this thesis focuses on revolutionary legacies in order to delve into a wider array of discourses engendered by antislavery debate. It delineates the overlapping and often conflicting concepts of Frenchness, race, and colonialism contested by the various groups who sought to define and appropriate revolutionary examples. By investigating the dispute over the status of colonial groups in the French national community—white planters, free people of color, and slaves—this work argues that the negotiations over French citizenship and Frenchness were at the center of the antislavery debate, with an emphasis on French citizenship’s complicated relation to race and colonialism. Third, this thesis ultimately shows how these contestations over revolutionary antislavery led to the formation of the dominant national discourse of French-given universal liberty, and how in this process the hegemonic narrative of the French Revolution and emancipation “silenced” the Haitian Revolution and Haiti.

FULL TEXT

RELATED CONTENT

The History of Peasants, Tonton Makouts, and the Rise and Fall of the Duvalier Dictatorship in Haiti

This dissertation analyzes the social and political history of Haitian peasants and the formation of the brutally repressive Duvalier dictatorship. It establishes that the rise of the dictatorship was the result of a political trajectory shaped by historical processes. In post- emancipated Haiti during the nineteenth century, thousands of peasants, who were formerly enslaved, joined the military and participated in insurrections to achieve high status and social mobility.

Read More »

The Economic Consequences of The Haitian Revolution

Haiti is among the poorest nations in the world and it is the single poorest country in the western hemisphere. Yet, Haiti once possessed the exact opposite connotation. Haiti was once the French colony of Saint-Domingue, the wealthiest, most profitable colony in the world. Saint-Domingue was France’s most prized possession and it became the prime destination for fortune seeking Frenchmen.

Read More »

The King, a Queen, and an Oath Sealed in Blood: A Cultural Re-Evaluation of the Bois-Caiman Ceremony and its Impact on the Early Haitian Revolution

Historical studies have set up a paradox where religious practices are discussed as socially important to enslaved people while simultaneously are described as peripheral to the outbreak of the Haitian Revolution. Yet at the heart of the lead up to the 1791 insurgency was an Afro-Caribbean religious event called the Bois-Caiman ceremony.

Read More »